Moral Luck Panel - Video & Photos
More special events

Punishing for Bad Luck: Should the Consequences of a Crime Affect the Punishment?
4 June 2008, Oxford Law Faculty (Lecture Theatre II)

A panel discussion with Professors Horder, Gardner and Ashworth, who have long disagreed over the answer to the above question. Thank you to the approx. 100 people who participated in the event!

This event was kindly sponsored by Hart Publishing, Oxford University Press and the Oxford Law Faculty.

Photos
Click here to open a slideshow.
Videos (click on image to start)
  • Videos are hosted at YouTube. Depending on the speed of your internet connection, you may experience breaks during the broadcast. In that case, it is recommended that you allow the videos to load fully (grey line) before watching them (you may press 'pause' while you wait for them to load).

  • The last 33 minutes (XIV Questions (6) and Conclusion) are only available as an audio file.




  I Introduction
II Horder (1)
III Horder (2)
IV Gardner (1)
V Gardner (2)
VI Gardner (3)

VII Ashworth (1)
  VIII Ashworth (2)
IX Questions (1)
X Questions (2)

XI Questions (3)
XII Questions (4)
XIII Questions (5)
XIV Questions (6) and Conclusion
 
I
Introduction
(6'12")
 
 
II
Horder
(1)
(7'25")
 
 
III
Horder
(2)
(4'49")
 
IV
Gardner (1)
(6'47")
 
 
V
Gardner (2)
(7'28")
 
 
VI
Gardner
(3)
(7'35")
 
 
VII
Ashworth
(1)
(6'55")
 
 
VIII
 
Ashworth (2)
(8'10")
 
 
IX
 
Questions (1)
(6'01")
 
 
X
 
Questions (2)
(8'13")
 
 
XI
 
Questions (3)
(4'15")
 
 
XII
 
Questions (4)
(4'40")
 
 
XIII
 
Questions (5)
(5'57)
 
 
XIV
 
Questions (6) and Conclusion
(audio 33')
 
 
 
 

 



To receive information about our events by email, please subscribe to our mailing list.


The Oxford Jurisprudence Discussion Group is kindly supported by Hart Publishing.


JDG Home | About this site

Check the Schedule for...
This term
This year
Past years
Special Events & Videos

More about the JDG:
Whence?
Where?
When?
What?
Who?
Why?

Getting in touch:
Contact us
Join the JDG mailing list

Some links:
JOT - test your jurisprudential orientation!
Oxford Jurisprudence
OxCEPL

European Academy of Legal Theory

A quotation:
“…for Hohfeld, as for other scientific pioneers, what seemed to them to be atoms may turn out to have been molecules” (C.F.H. Tapper)


A date:
29 Apr 2009 (Wed), first Scanlon Locke Lecture on Reasons

A picture: